Commissioned by the BBC

  • 1+pic.1+ca.2+bcl.2/3221/3perc/hp.cel/str
  • 24 min

Programme Note

I. Very Still, Intense; Moderato
II. Spacious, Still; Lightly Dancing
III. Spacious; Gently Flowing; Always Simple

My concerto is in a conventional three-movement form. However, the standard formal pattern of fast–slow–fast is replaced by moderato–fast–slow; the second movement flows straight into the third; and the first two movements open with similar material, which will surface again in the final one.

Reshaping convention like this comes from wanting to write music that is connected to the familiar and traditional, but which also embraces the less familiar and contemporary. In this way, I hope to widen my means of expression, and also to create fresh musical relationships. So, tonal sonorities rub up against, or elide with, more dissonant ones; simple rhythms, when superimposed, lead to poly-metric richness; harmonies progress but also circle; harmonic colours range from basic intervals to complex clusters.

In this concerto, these mixtures form a long-range, expressive journey – moving from struggle to release, a recurring narrative in my music. It begins with a simple, two note oscillating pattern in the solo violin. This music is stable and sweet, but also sounds strained because the soloist plays high up on the lowest string of the violin. The stability doesn’t last, and the main body of the movement is a striving flux of ideas – led by the soloist, increasingly echoed and amplified in the orchestra – which cannot settle. The second movement returns briefly to the quiet stability of the opening of the first, but it too quickly gives way to newly searching music. At first this is filled with rocking, repeating, even child-like patterns, emphasized by bright instrumental sonorities. But these sounds intensify and darken: the known leading to the less known.

At the end of the second movement, the earthy dance that has emerged lifts away into something more ethereal. However, before this can feel like real repose, the final movement cuts in with a fortissimo, minor triad in the strings. I hope, in this context, tonality takes on the element of surprise and rupture. Twice more, triads interrupt. But the third time, variants of the oscillating motif – first on the horns, then in the solo part – enter too, leading to an emotional climax and introspective solo violin cadenza. This releases, in turn, into a reprise of the two-note figure at its original pitch, answered by passages of gently intermingling orchestral lines. In the long, final settling, the soloist rises through the texture to reach the motif again, which reduces down to a single high A, insistent and repeating. At the very end, the work’s opening harmony reappears. For me it is something re-found and heard anew. But it floats away almost before it is fully registered.

The concerto was commissioned by the BBC and was first performed by Carolin Widmann and the BBC Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sakari Oramo at the Barbican concert hall, London, on 3 February 2017. When I worked initially with Carolin Widmann on the piece, we discussed how passionate she was about making the violin sing. It was inspiring to hear just how many nuances of singing she could bring to the instrument, intense and open, strained and fragile, passionate and vibrato-filled, delicate and almost innocent. I’ve tried to make the most of these different voices - to move from the habitual to paths less travelled, and, at the concerto’s close, from struggle to contemplation.

Programme note by Michael Zev Gordon

Media

Scores

Reviews

...suffused through-and-through with warm humanity. But it too expressed a sense of something that couldn’t be quite said out loud. The perilously high two-note repeated phrase at the opening was played by soloist Carolin Widmann with rapturous sweetness, but also a stifled quality, as if couldn’t “speak”. Though the piece roamed far and wide, with a slow movement and a tenderly dancing scherzo, it kept coming back to that opening phrase. The whole piece felt like an attempt to unlock the mystery of this phrase, but the final frustrated repeated notes seemed like an admission of defeat: moving, in its way.

Ivan Hewett, The Telegraph
30th October 2021
...the work’s qualities of transparency and – in the middle movement – playfulness registered exquisitely.
The Telegraph
…a quietly arresting piece…
The Times
He’s not a predictable or conventional composer, though he has a positively forensic interest in musical tradition and the notions of collective memory it enshrines…the piece contains nothing to alarm the ear, and much to seduce it…The concerto attests the virtue of solid craftsmanship, but seemed to have much to say beyond that, even if it cannot readily – or ever – be put in words.
The Sunday Times
Gordon’s music deals in abstracts – new and old, familiar and unfamiliar, simple and complex – but with an unusual directness and clarity of expression. The concerto is not a virtuoso showpiece, but rather an exploration of the lyrical and expressive qualities of Widmann’s playing. It proved an ideal match, with Widmann here making the best possible case for the new work.
The Arts Desk
Gordon…has built up a distinctive and thought-provoking output. The three movements may have formal antecedents in Prokofiev and Walton, but Gordon’s handling of this, as of the music’s harmonic profile, is most often personal. Szymanowski came to mind in the first movement; the soloist providing a melodic continuity to which the orchestra responds with equivocal gestures that take on greater agitation in a ‘scherzo’ whose latent aggression comes to the fore. An airy ascent into the finale brings a plangent emotional release that, via the deftest of cadenzas, gradually regains much of the initial poise; before settling into a rapt postlude during which the soloist’s terse opening motif returns…as the music recedes elegantly, and not a little regretfully, beyond earshot.
Classical Source

Discography

The Impermanence of Things

The Impermanence of Things
  • Label
    NMC
  • Catalogue Number
    NMC D277
  • Conductor
    Jukka-Pekka Saraste / Catherine Larsen-Maguire / Ryan Wigglesworth
  • Ensemble
    BBC Symphony Orchestra / BBC National Orchestra of Wales / London Sinfonietta
  • Soloist
    Carolin Widmann, violin; Huw Watkins, piano; Ian Dearden, electronics
  • Released
    19th April 2024

More Info